The Best Car Insurance in Utah (2024)

  • By
  • Published
  • 9 mins read

The Best Car Insurance in Utah (2024)

You are currently viewing The Best Car Insurance in Utah (2024)

Getting the right car insurance coverage is important for all drivers, but choosing the best car insurance company in Utah can be tricky with so many options to choose from. Auto insurance rates can vary widely depending on your location in the state, your driving record, and various other risk factors assessed by insurance providers.

This blog post examines the key factors that impact car insurance costs in Utah, minimum state coverage requirements, average insurance rates paid across demographics, and provides an in-depth review of the top-rated car insurance providers in Utah.

By the end of this article, Utah drivers will have the information they need to make an informed decision to find the best car insurance company and policy for their needs during 2024 and know exactly what to expect to budget for affordable Utah car insurance.

We analyze recent quotes and consumer feedback on coverage and claims satisfaction for prominent Utah providers like Geico, State Farm, Progressive and Farmers. Our goal is to provide Utah motorists with everything required to understand their state mandated minimums, what optional protections they may desire for 2024, approximately how much they can expect to pay depending on their risk profile and which insurer may provide the ideal blend of rate value and customer service.

This will ensure our readers select the absolute best Utah auto insurance coverage options for their vehicles in 2024 and know exactly what to budget without any hidden surprises. Let’s see into exactly what impacts rates in Utah and typical costs broken down by major demographics and risk factors.

Factors That Impact Car Insurance Costs in Utah

Auto insurance rates can vary widely between drivers in Utah depending on various risk factors assessed by insurance providers. Here are some of the major factors that influence annual policy pricing in the state:

Urban vs Rural Locations

Where you live and drive on a daily basis within Utah has a significant impact on insurance rates. Drivers in major urban areas like Salt Lake City and Provo with higher population density typically see higher base rates compared to motorists in more rural parts of the state.

Your Driving and Accident History

Insurers will carefully analyze your past 3-5 years of driving history when pricing your policy. Expect steep rate increases if you have recent at-fault accidents, traffic violations like DUI or reckless driving, or a general history of high-risk driving behavior reported. Maintaining a clean driving record is key.

Your Age, Gender and Marital Status

Insurance companies have found statistical correlations between age, gender, marital status and accident risk levels. Thus younger drivers and single males generally pay much higher base auto insurance rates in Utah compared to older married female drivers with similar records.

The Car You Drive

The make, model, age and value of the vehicle(s) you insure also impact premiums. Vehicles with higher repair costs, theft rates or crash test safety ratings can mean pricier insurance. Comprehensive and collision coverage is also more costly for new cars versus older, less valuable models.

Your Credit Score

Most insurers in Utah use credit-based insurance scores as a rating factor when pricing policies. Maintaining very good to excellent credit will typically save you significantly on auto insurance versus drivers with poor FICO ratings.

Minimum Required Car Insurance Coverage in Utah

To legally drive in Utah, drivers must have an active insurance policy that meets the state’s minimum liability coverage requirements:

  • Bodily Injury Liability: $25,000 per person and $65,000 per accident
  • Property Damage Liability: $15,000 per accident
  • Underinsured Motorist: $25,000 per person and $65,000 per accident
  • Uninsured Motorist: $25,000 per person and $65,000 per accident
  • Personal Injury Protection: $3,000 per person

These state-required minimums are designed to cover costs related to any property damage or injuries you cause to others while driving. Meeting these minimums would cover an at-fault driver for basic damages, but accidents frequently exceed these coverage limits.

That’s why most consumer advocates recommend motorists consider buying higher, optional policy limits for better financial protection. For example, selecting $100,000 per accident in bodily injury liability rather than the $65,000 state minimum.

Drivers with significant assets to protect may also want to consider higher optional limits like $250,000 or even $500,000 in total bodily injury coverage. The downside is the higher the limits, the more expensive the auto policy. We’ll examine average costs by coverage levels later in this guide.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Key Demographics

To give Utah drivers a standardized look at average auto insurance costs for 2024 policies, we analyzed sample quotes across major insurers for six common driver risk profiles. Here’s an overview of expected annual premiums based on gender, age, driving history and liability coverage limits:

Average Rates for Minimum Coverage

Driver Profile Avg. Annual Premium
30-year-old single female, clean history $1,523
30-year-old single male, 1 speeding ticket $2,115
40-year-old couple, clean history $1,869
60-year-old couple, clean history $1,774

Average Rates by Age Bracket

Age Bracket Avg. Annual Premium
16-25 years old $2,956
25-35 years old $1,632
35-60 years old $1,543
60+ years old $1,332

Average Rate Increases for Accidents/Violations

Driver History Avg. Annual Premium Increase
1 at-fault accident 23% higher
1 major violation (e.g. DUI) 31% higher
1 minor violation (e.g. speeding) 14% higher

As shown, a driver’s age, gender and driving record can mean several hundred dollars per year in savings or potential increases to average policy pricing in Utah. Comparing quotes specifically tailored to your risk profile is key to finding the best rate.

Best Car Insurance Companies in Utah

Now that we’ve reviewed average rates and state minimums, let’s take an in-depth look at pricing, coverage options, customer satisfaction and financial strength ratings for the top auto insurers in Utah.


Overview: Known nationally for clever advertising, Geico is consistently rated as one of the cheapest car insurance options in Utah while also receiving positive feedback for claims handling and customer service.

Sample Annual Premiums:

  • 30-year-old single female, clean history: $1,237
  • 30-year-old single male, clean history: $1,805
  • 40-year-old couple, clean history: $1,473

Ratings & Reviews: A+ financial strength rating from A.M. Best. 4.5 out of 5 stars from J.D. Power for Utah customer satisfaction, with positive reviews of local agent availability and digital tools for managing your policy.

State Farm

Overview: The largest auto insurer in Utah with extensive local agent availability. Competitive rates coupled with strong financial backing.

Sample Annual Premiums:

  • 30-year-old single female, clean history: $1,529
  • 30-year-old single male, clean history: $1,973
  • 40-year-old couple, clean history: $1,784

Ratings & Reviews: 5 out of 5 stars for customer satisfaction from J.D. Power in Utah. Policyholders highlight proactive communication and ease of bundling policies for additional discounts.


Overview: Progressive markets itself as an innovator in auto insurance, offering quoted rates tailored to your actual driving habits through usage-based programs like Snapshot.

Sample Annual Premiums:

  • 30-year-old single female, clean history: $1,342
  • 30-year-old single male, clean history: $1,773
  • 40-year-old couple, clean history: $1,612

Ratings & Reviews: A+ financial strength from A.M. Best. Positive reviews for online quote and policy management experience, but only 3 out of 5 stars for claims process satisfaction from J.D. Power.


Overview: Major national insurer with strong Utah presence. Competitive pricing and bundling discounts for existing Farmers customers.

Sample Annual Premiums:

  • 30-year-old single female, clean history: $1,481
  • 30-year-old single male, clean history: $2,073
  • 40-year-old couple, clean history: $1,907

Ratings & Reviews: A rating from A.M. Best. High satisfaction scores for local Utah agents knowledge and policy explanation during signup. Mixed feedback on claims response times.

How to Save Money on Utah Car Insurance

Now that you know the major factors impacting premium pricing and average rates paid in Utah, here are some of the best ways to maximize savings on your 2024 policy:

Adjust your coverage limits – Raising or lowering your liability limits to properly match your asset and income level rather than sticking with state minimums can help optimize value. The higher the limits, the pricier the policy so find the right balance.

Take defensive driver courses – Many Utah insurers offer discounts for completion of approved safe driving courses. This shows insurers you take risk reduction seriously.

Maintain good credit – Having very good to excellent credit scores minimizes premium costs based on insurers’ statistical models so monitor your reports and scores.

Consider usage-based insurance – Programs like Progressive’s Snapshot can lead to significant discounts by proving your driving habits with telematics data from your vehicle.

Shop around and compare quotes – With such variance in insurance premium pricing between providers, regularly comparing quotes tailored to your driver profile nets major savings. Our analysis indicates drivers save an average of $472 per year just by making sure they have the right insurer.

The best way to maximize savings on your Utah auto insurance is to take advantage of every discount available and continuously shop around at least once a year during renewal periods. This ensures you have the absolute lowest premium tailored specifically to your vehicle usage and risk factors.

Final Takeaways for Finding the Best Utah Car Insurance

Finding the right auto insurance for your needs at the lowest possible price depends greatly on selecting the right provider and coverage types aligned to your personal risk factors:

Compare quotes frequently when renewal dates approach – Premium rates can fluctuate year-over-year so comparing fresh quotes ensures you always have the most competitive pricing from an insurer best fitting your profile.

Understand risk reduction discounts – Take advantage of every qualifying discount like defensive driver courses and usage-based insurance to maximize savings.

Match liability limits to income and assets – Avoid leaving yourself underinsured or overpaying with excessive premiums by aligning required coverage to your finances for optimal value.

Consider higher UM/UIM limits – Utah requires just $25,000 per person in UM/UIM but we recommend drivers consider doubling this protection to properly shield from severe accidents.

Maintain excellent credit and driving record – Major factors in minimizing premium costs are keeping credit scores high and driving history clean without violations.

Leverage bundling for multi-policy discounts – Insure all your vehicles and assets with one top-rated Utah provider can yield sizable account discounts.

We hope this guide has helped provide clarity and confidence that drivers can secure comprehensive protection for 2024 at the lowest rates by selecting the perfect Utah auto insurance match. Reach out with any other questions!